What’s The History Of Movie Reviewing?




Affiliate Disclaimer

As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.

Ever since the first moving pictures flickered on the silver screen, people have been eager to share their thoughts and opinions on what they have watched. Movie reviewing has a rich and fascinating history, evolving alongside the film industry itself. From the early days of written critiques in newspapers to the rise of internet-based platforms, the act of reviewing movies has become an important part of the cinematic experience. In this article, we will explore the history of movie reviewing, from its humble beginnings to its current role in shaping the film industry. Whether you are a film student, industry professional, or simply someone with a passion for movies, join us as we delve into the fascinating world of movie reviewing.

Whats The History Of Movie Reviewing?

Table of Contents

Early Beginnings

The origins of movie reviewing

Movie reviewing can trace its origins back to the early days of cinema. As soon as movies began to captivate audiences, discussions and debates about their quality and artistic merit arose. The first known movie review was published in 1907 by the French magazine “Le Bon Film,” where critics shared their opinions on the short film “The Assassination of the Duke of Guise.” This marked the beginning of a practice that would evolve over the years.

The role of early critics

During the silent film era, movie reviewing played a crucial role in helping audiences navigate the vast number of films being produced. Critics took on the responsibility of guiding people towards worthwhile films and cautioning them against mediocre or poorly made ones. These early critics were often journalists or writers who possessed a deep understanding of the medium and its technical aspects. Their reviews provided valuable insights into the storytelling techniques, performances, and visual aesthetics of the films.

The Rise of Film Journalism

The emergence of dedicated film publications

With the growth of the film industry and the increasing popularity of movies, dedicated film publications started to emerge in the early 20th century. Magazines like “Photoplay” and “Variety” began publishing articles and reviews that focused solely on cinema. These publications not only celebrated the art of filmmaking but also sparked conversations about the cultural significance and societal impact of movies.

The influence of film societies and clubs

Film societies and clubs, such as the Film Society of Lincoln Center in New York, played a significant role in popularizing film criticism. These organizations hosted screenings of classic films and provided platforms for intellectuals and enthusiasts to discuss and analyze the cinematic art form. The conversations and debates held within these societies helped shape the way films were perceived and critiqued.

The impact of the Hollywood studio system

During the Golden Age of Hollywood, the rise of the studio system had a profound impact on film journalism. Studios maintained close relationships with critics, often providing them with privileged access to film screenings and exclusive interviews with filmmakers and stars. This relationship created a symbiotic dynamic where studios benefited from positive reviews, while critics gained access and exposure to the industry. However, this close association also raised questions about the objectivity of film criticism.

The Golden Age of Film Criticism

Prominent film critics and their contributions

The Golden Age of Film Criticism saw the rise of influential critics whose writings continue to be revered and studied today. Critics such as Roger Ebert, Pauline Kael, and Andrew Sarris reshaped the landscape of film criticism through their insightful analyses, eloquent writing styles, and unique perspectives. Their contributions not only influenced public opinion but also challenged filmmakers and the industry to strive for excellence in storytelling and craftsmanship.

The establishment of film criticism as a profession

As film criticism gained prominence and recognition, it evolved into a legitimate profession. Critics began working for established newspapers, magazines, and broadcasting networks, dedicating their careers to analyzing and evaluating the latest films. They received assignments, attended press screenings, and were tasked with providing informed opinions about the artistic and commercial aspects of movies. This professionalization of film criticism added a greater sense of accountability to the field.

Influence of film criticism on public opinion

Film criticism has long been recognized as having the power to shape public opinion. Through their writings, critics can champion noteworthy films, shed light on underappreciated gems, and warn audiences about potential disappointments. Positive reviews from respected critics frequently drive audiences to theaters, while negative reviews can have the opposite effect. Film criticism influences not only which movies people choose to watch but also how they perceive and appreciate the art of cinema.

The Evolution of Movie Reviewing

Introduction of star ratings and review aggregators

In an effort to condense and simplify movie reviews, the practice of assigning star ratings to films emerged. This allowed readers to quickly gauge the overall critical reception of a movie. Alongside star ratings, review aggregators like Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic gained popularity by compiling reviews from various sources and calculating aggregated scores. These platforms gave audiences a comprehensive overview of a film’s critical consensus.

The advent of online movie reviewing platforms

With the advent of the internet, movie reviewing experienced a paradigm shift. Online platforms such as IMDb, Letterboxd, and YouTube provided a space for anyone with an opinion to share their thoughts on movies. This democratization of film criticism allowed for more diverse voices and perspectives to enter the conversation. However, it also led to an oversaturation of film reviews and made it challenging for audiences to discern reliable and insightful opinions.

The impact of social media on movie reviewing

Social media platforms like Twitter, Instagram, and TikTok have transformed the landscape of film reviewing. Through hashtags, threads, and videos, users can express their opinions about movies in real-time, potentially reaching a large audience. Social media has fostered a sense of community among film enthusiasts, allowing for spirited discussions, debates, and the formation of online fandoms. However, it has also contributed to a culture of instant reactions and oversimplification of complex film analysis.

Whats The History Of Movie Reviewing?

Ethics in Movie Reviewing

Conflict of interest in film criticism

As film criticism evolved into a profession, concerns regarding conflicts of interest arose. Critics who maintain close relationships with filmmakers, actors, or studios may face ethical dilemmas when reviewing their work. Instances of bias and favoritism have been debated, challenging the integrity of some reviews. Disclosing potential conflicts of interest and maintaining objectivity are essential aspects of ethical movie reviewing.

The responsibility of a film critic

Film critics bear the responsibility of providing honest and informed evaluations of movies. Their analyses should go beyond personal preferences and encompass a wider understanding of cinema as an art form. A good film critic offers insightful interpretations, explores the cultural and social context of the film, and considers the technical aspects that contribute to its overall quality. Critics should strive to be fair, balanced, and transparent in their assessments.

The influence of biases and personal opinions

Like any form of critique, film reviews can be influenced by personal biases, preferences, and subjective opinions. Critics must recognize and acknowledge their own biases to maintain credibility and fairness. Readers should also be aware of the critic’s unique taste and perspective, allowing them to consider different viewpoints and form their own opinions about a film.

The Impact of Movie Reviews

Effect of positive and negative reviews on box office performance

Movie reviews have the power to significantly impact a film’s box office performance. Positive reviews from respected critics can generate buzz and attract audiences, leading to increased ticket sales. Conversely, a consensus of negative reviews can discourage potential viewers and result in poor box office numbers. The critical reception of a film often influences its commercial success and longevity in theaters.

The power of film criticism in shaping public perception

Film criticism plays a crucial role in shaping public perception of movies. Positive reviews can elevate lesser-known films, bringing them to the attention of wider audiences and potentially increasing their cultural impact. Conversely, negative reviews can contribute to a film being dismissed or forgotten. Film criticism influences how films are discussed, remembered, and valued by society.

The influence on award nominations and wins

Movie reviews also play a significant role in the award season. Critical acclaim can propel a film to nominations and wins, as awards voters often consider the opinions of respected critics when making their decisions. Positive reviews can raise awareness of specific performances, technical achievements, and overall artistic excellence, contributing to a film’s chances of receiving recognition and accolades.

Whats The History Of Movie Reviewing?

Controversies in Movie Reviewing

The debate on the objectivity of film criticism

The question of whether film criticism can ever be truly objective has been a subject of much debate. Critics have different perspectives, tastes, and biases that shape their opinions. Some argue that objectivity in film criticism is impossible, as the evaluation of a movie depends on individual perception and personal experiences. Others believe in the importance of holding critics to objective standards and emphasizing measurable qualities like technical proficiency and storytelling coherence.

The role of diversity and representation in reviews

The lack of diversity and representation in film criticism has been a longstanding issue. Historically, critics were predominantly white and male, leading to a limited range of perspectives being represented in reviews. The push for increased representation and diversity has highlighted the importance of including a wider array of voices in the conversation. Critics from different backgrounds and experiences can offer unique insights and challenge the often homogenous narrative surrounding film.

The backlash against criticism and the rise of fan culture

In the age of social media, film criticism has faced backlash from passionate fans and fandoms. Some fans perceive critiques of their favorite movies as personal attacks and engage in online campaigns to discredit or silence critics. This backlash has contributed to the rise of fan culture, where passionate fans use online platforms to defend and promote their favorite films, often disregarding critical evaluation. This trend has sparked important discussions about the role of criticism and the separation of personal taste from objective analysis.

The Future of Movie Reviewing

The changing landscape of film journalism

Film journalism continues to evolve as technology advances and new platforms emerge. Traditional print publications have faced challenges in adapting to the digital age, leading to a shift towards online platforms and multimedia content. Journalists are now exploring innovative formats such as podcasts, video essays, and interactive articles to engage with audiences in new and exciting ways. The future of film journalism lies in embracing technological advancements while maintaining the core principles of critical analysis and storytelling.

The role of user-generated reviews

User-generated reviews have become a significant part of the film reviewing landscape. Platforms like IMDb and Letterboxd allow users to rate and review movies, influencing public perception and providing a diverse range of opinions. While user reviews offer valuable perspectives from the general audience, they also present challenges in terms of reliability and expertise. The future will require a balance between professional criticism and user-generated content to ensure that diverse voices are heard without sacrificing quality analysis.

The potential of AI in movie reviewing

Artificial Intelligence (AI) presents both opportunities and challenges for movie reviewing. AI-powered algorithms can analyze vast amounts of data, including critical reception and audience preferences, to generate predictions about a film’s success. While AI has the potential to enhance efficiency and provide valuable insights, it also raises concerns about the loss of human expertise, subjectivity, and the personal connection between critic and audience. The future of movie reviewing will likely involve a thoughtful integration of AI alongside human expertise and judgment.

The Influence of Movie Reviewers

Critics who have shaped the industry

Throughout history, numerous film critics have left an indelible mark on the industry. Roger Ebert, known for his accessible writing style and passionate advocacy for cinema, became an influential figure whose opinions were widely respected. Pauline Kael challenged conventional wisdom and brought a new level of artistry and intellectual rigor to film criticism. Andrew Sarris introduced the concept of the “auteur theory,” which emphasized the director as the primary creative force behind a film. These critics, among others, have shaped the discourse and appreciation of film on a global scale.

Critics turned filmmakers and industry professionals

Some film critics have made the transition from reviewing films to actually making them. Filmmakers like François Truffaut and Peter Bogdanovich started their careers as critics, using their in-depth knowledge of cinema to create groundbreaking movies. Their fluency in the language of film criticism informed their artistic choices and resulted in innovative storytelling techniques. Similarly, critics such as Kenneth Turan and Owen Gleiberman have become respected industry professionals, using their expertise to contribute to the filmmaking process beyond reviewing.

The impact of influential film critics

Influential film critics have had a lasting impact on the film industry, shaping the trajectory of filmmakers and influencing audience tastes. Their writings have challenged conventions, pushed boundaries, and expanded the possibilities of cinema. By championing visionary directors, supporting independent films, and promoting underrepresented voices, these critics have played a crucial role in elevating the art form and ensuring its continued relevance.

Film Reviews and Cultural Impact

Film criticism as a form of art and cultural expression

Film criticism itself can be viewed as a form of art and cultural expression. Critics employ various writing styles, rhetorical devices, and persuasive techniques to engage readers and convey their opinions effectively. Through their analyses and interpretations, film critics contribute to the ongoing dialogue about the cultural importance of movies and their impact on society. Critics provide insights that enrich our understanding of films, enabling us to appreciate their artistic choices and thematic depth.

The portrayal of films and filmmakers in reviews

Film reviews often provide a platform for discussing not only the films themselves but also the stories of the filmmakers behind them. Critics delve into the creative processes, inspirations, and struggles of directors, writers, actors, and other key contributors. These discussions shed light on the challenges faced by artists in bringing their visions to the screen, as well as the societal and cultural contexts that shape their work. Film reviews serve as windows into the world of filmmaking, revealing the human stories behind the movies we watch.

The influence on film scholarship and academia

Film criticism has had a profound impact on film scholarship and academia. Critics’ analyses and interpretations have inspired scholarly research, providing valuable reference points for exploring cinematic themes, historical contexts, and cultural trends. Many universities now offer courses and programs dedicated to the study of film criticism, recognizing its role in shaping film theory and the broader field of cultural studies. Film reviews continue to be studied, analyzed, and debated within academic circles, contributing to a deeper understanding of cinema as an art form and cultural phenomenon.

In conclusion, movie reviewing has a rich history that has evolved alongside the film industry itself. From humble origins to the rise of dedicated publications and the establishment of film criticism as a profession, reviewers have played a critical role in shaping public opinion, influencing box office performance, and contributing to the cultural discourse surrounding cinema. While movie reviewing continues to face challenges, such as ethics and the impact of social media, the future holds exciting possibilities with the changing landscape of film journalism, the inclusion of diverse voices, and the potential integration of AI. Film reviews have not only influenced public perception and the careers of filmmakers but have also achieved cultural significance as a form of art and expression. Through critical analysis and interpretation, film critics provide valuable insights that enhance our understanding and appreciation of the cinematic medium.

About the author

Latest posts